| |
2
Challenges and their Implications
Despite
all of the afore-mentioned problems, the achievements made
by the health system in Sri Lanka over the past decades are
many fold compared to other developing countries. However,
over the past years the integrity of the Health System has
been subjected to many challenges. Sri Lanka is already facing
emerging challenges such as challenges due to demographical,
epidemiological, technological and social transitions. The
country displays the typical double burden of disease, with
a mixed but shifting morbidity and mortality due to communicable
diseases and non-communicable diseases and questionable quality
of care. These challenges require significant changes in the
ways in which health services are funded, resourced, managed,
and provided.
2.1 Responding to Changing Disease and Demographic Pattern
The morbidity and mortality trends are changing
and demands new service delivery priorities to be established.
The population structure is also changing with an increasing
proportion of the population being elderly. It is expected
that this segment of the population will make increasing demands
on the health service, particularly in their last decade of
life.
Non-communicable diseases are increasing not only as a proportion
of the burden of disease, but also in incidence and prevalence.
Among the more important of these are accidents, heart disease,
mental illness, diabetes and cancers. Diagnostic and treatment
technologies for many such diseases are expensive and outcomes
are often poor, but once new technologies are introduced and
made freely available, the demanded for such would be enormous.
Some of these technologies achieve relatively little in terms
of health outcome but incur large costs, while some are effective.
The new technologies introduced to the country first by the
private sector will quickly affect demand and supply in the
state sector and can be a major factor in cost escalation.
The prevention of non-communicable diseases is generally
a highly cost-effective use of state funding and can be achieved,
to some extent, through accident prevention, injury limitation,
healthy diets and lifestyle, reduction in smoking etc.. However,
some conditions are chronic and require lifelong treatment
or containment. Whilst new problems are emerging, some health
problems of the last century still remain at alarming levels.
The maternal anaemia rate remain at 35% and childhood malnutrition,
which is still thought to be as high as 29% (weight for age)
in under fives - a figure which sits uncomfortably alongside
Sri Lanka's significant reduction in infant mortality rates.
A reduction in malnutrition rates requires targeted education,
plus in some cases directs food supplements at community level
in the immediate term and poverty reduction measures in the
medium term. Many interventions have not delivered and further
analysis is required to learn lessons from these experiences.
Malaria remains significant, and potentially serious, although
more than half of cases are in the North East and with the
restoration of services there are likely to reduce further
over the next few years. Dengue and Tuberculosis also pose
significant risks. HIV/AIDS is a totally new challenge. Prevalence
is still low and there is a window of opportunity to ensure
that it remains so. There is a need to strengthen surveillance
systems, undertake further research and evaluation, revisit
the role of field staff and other sectors and to review inter-sectoral
experiences.
2.2 Service Delivery and Levels of Care Currently
Sri Lanka has a multiplicity of categories of health facilities
and therefore it is often confusing to patients where to get
appropriate care. It is proposed to have only four levels
of care with a firm commitment to quality of care at all levels.
Referral and counter referrals need to be clearly formalized
and monitored, and supplies and drugs have to be ordered and
stocked taking the counter referral possibility into account
for the most frequent diseases so that the primary level which
will provide the follow up would be conversant with the situation.
As the size of population served varies with population density,
the volume of services planned too would vary from institution
to institution. But the services offered should be uniformal
within a level and will be clearly announced. In principle
it is accepted that health facilities with a curative role
should increasingly take on secondary and tertiary prevention
especially in chronic communicable and non-communicable diseases.
Similarly it is accepted that primary preventive units will
have to take on more primary prevention tasks in relation
to non-communicable diseases.
What is not yet clear is the scope of preventive facilities
and the number of workers who will fulfill primary care and
curative follow-up activities with screening of diseases and
work towards patient and family-centred promotion and prevention.
The prevailing paradigm is to use a campaign approach for
prevention and restrict patient-centred services for secondary
and tertiary care. It is questionable as to how far this paradigm
can serve the emergent as well as the prevailing epidemiological
challenges.
There are various branches of medicine in Sri Lanka, which
contribute to the nations health. They include Unani, Ayuvedha
and Homeopathy and other systems of medicine. All of them
collectively constitute an integral part of the health sector
and must be included in the planning process. The development
of these systems needs to be ensured by a clearer conceptual
basis for coordination of health services, coupled with adequate
resource allocation and the strengthening of the existing
institutions.
2.3. Improving Management and Stewardship At the
turn of the 21st century the health system faces several major
problems in its organization and management. One major issue
is the confusion and attendant conflicts over roles, responsibilities
and lines of accountability between central and provincial
levels of the MoH, consequent to devolution.
In the past the state health service has been well administered,
but the modern environment now requires the services to be
well managed. This requires greater delegation, clear accountability,
flexibility and freedom for managers to manage, development
and implementation of the concepts of good governance, the
development of management and financial information systems
that encourage and reward the achievement of results and a
focus on outputs rather than inputs. At present managerial
and financial systems are inadequate and there is shortage
of trained staff. In addition the health information system
is also beset with many challenges. Lack of an updated policy
for information, insufficient coordination among managers
of information, uneven information management capacity, substandard
quality of the existing data and sub optimal use of information
and other technology are important challenges that need to
be overcome.
The need to update the health legislation, enhancing effectiveness,
efficiency and accountability of the MOH through improved
human and financial management, strengthening of managerial
performance at provincial and sub-provincial levels with improved
capacity and capability to handle decentralized responsibility
for managing health care services, strengthening of monitoring
and evaluation of health service quality & delivery and
enhancing evidence-based decision making by the MOH and other
institutions are important challenges for the new centaury.
2.4 Maximizing the Private Sector Contribution While
Sri Lanka prides itself for a well established public sector
for health care provision, the private sector plays a significant
role in the health sector. The Government tacitly encourages
individuals to pay for their own health care where they are
able to do so and for the private health sector to meet these
needs. However, Government has an overall responsibility for
ensuring that patients are protected and get value for money
in both state and private sectors. As such Government needs
to consider how to regulate the private health sector without
stifling initiative and innovation. Consideration also needs
to be given to how best to encourage partnerships between
state and private sectors to deliver quality services and
contribute to the national health goals. Strengthening of
the capacity of the private health sector to provide quality
care too is emphasized.
2.5 Human Resource Management Despite the increasing
numbers of specific categories of Human Resources in the health
sector the past years have witnessed many problems and challenges.
In addition to the shortages of certain cadres of staff, the
growing surplus of doctors will have serious cost and quality
implications. These doctors may not be properly absorbed into
the state health system, although there is an historic commitment
to do so. Even if these doctors move into the private sector,
a surplus of doctors practicing privately will cause an increase
in supply-driven consumption levels. On the other hand, there
are serious disparities in the requirements and supply of
other categories of health personnel, particularly nurses
and paramedical personnel.
One of the recurrent constraints for improving the effectiveness
of human resource policy and planning in the health sector
is the lack of a comprehensive human resource strategy. There
is a significant imbalance existing in the distribution of
HRH among districts. Specifically the number and the rate
of health personnel in the Northern Province is extremely
low while districts such as Colombo, Kandy and Galle have
a significantly higher concentration.
The insufficient quality and competency of health staff too
has been identified as a challenge for correction. Lack of
technical competency and absence of positive humane attitudes
have been identified in turn to maximize the responsiveness
of the services.
In terms of employment structures and human resource management,
Sri Lanka still retains a system whereby certain categories
of state sector staff are appointed and controlled by a Public
Service Commission or similar state bodies. There are also
weaknesses in the recruitment and deployment of other categories
of staff. These result in distant, slow and largely unresponsive
administration of staff as they strive to work in a changing
environment. The challenge is to introduce a modern system
of management geared to the defined roles and performance
of individuals and institutions. This will require an improvement
in the working conditions of staff, a fair and transparent
system for promotion, reward, discipline and training, re-certification
processes and revised terms and conditions that will generate
different incentives for staff who are more responsive to
clients needs. Appropriate conflict resolution procedures
need to be introduced.
2.6 Living with Limited Financial Resources
The predictions based on the studies done to estimate the
financial burden of the health system for the next fifteen
years clearly show the extent of the additional funds needed
to run the health system. In order to maximize the resource
utilization there is significant pressure to make best use
of the limited financial resources available. Central Government
financial allocations to Provincial Councils are not based
on objective and transparent measures of population need -
only around 6% of funding is via 'criteria - based' grants
(weighted favourably towards the poorer provinces).
Block grants from the Ministry of Provincial Councils constitute
the largest component of funding for provinces. Provision
of 'matching grants' was aimed at encouraging local revenue
rising but it does not seem to have been achieved. In practice,
there is no attempt to link national policy to finance through
this allocative mechanism. There is neither a contracting
mechanism nor is there any evaluation of value for money.
Also there is a need to ensure that equitable and fair distribution
mechanisms are in place between and within provinces and that
these address localized poverty pressures.
With the existing resource allocation mechanisms there is
little opportunity for significant improvement in service
efficiency, cost effectiveness, quality or ability to focus
on the poor without a substantial change. This necessitates
the inclusion of more management autonomy, improvements in
finance and management systems and financing including allocations
based on needs, together with more rational planning and funding
of services.
2.7 Improving Responsiveness
There is a growing consumer dissatisfaction with the services
rendered by most of the state owned health care facilities
and patients are becoming more inclined to express their dissatisfaction.
The issues that are particular causes for concern include
overcrowding in the larger hospitals, long waiting times,
poor surroundings and the unsatisfactory attitudes of some
health care workers. Issues of professional negligence are
being raised strongly in the national press and recent cases
have involved individuals suing the Government for compensation
for negligence. There is little or no information on consumer
views about the private sector. More information is required
on the attitudes and perceptions of the public on the services
they receive and appropriate systems will be developed for
complaints to be heard and problems resolved.
2.8 The Challenges of the Conflict Affected Areas
The WHO report, Proposal for Recovery of the Health System
of Conflict Affected Areas Sri Lanka, September 2002, established
an Emergency and Humanitarian Action programme to meet the
short term needs of the conflict affected communities leading
into mid to long term strategies for health system recovery.
A short-term programme has been developed and is being implemented
focusing on re-establishing the district health system, establishing
a multi - disease surveillance system and providing essential
health services based on primary health care.
The approach should be institutionalized and a clear strategy
developed to ensure a smooth transition from emergency to
development support. The requirement is for the smooth transition
of the emergency aid to sustainable health management. Similarly,
it is essential that international assistance is maximally
utilized to support the rebuilding with a rational plan for
services that can be staffed and resourced. The methodology
of a sector wide approach would be of considerable benefit
in ensuring this.
2.9 Focusing on Vulnerable Groups
The challenge remains to ensure that Government funds in
the health sector are targeted towards the poor and most vulnerable
in society while that those who can afford to pay are encouraged
to do so. Whilst Sri Lanka has been exceptionally successful
by international standards in targeting state funds to poorer
groups, significant gaps remain - notably for the elderly,
the disabled, women, adolescents, those affected by conflict
and workers in the estates sector.
2.10 A Sector Wide Approach and Inter-sectoral Collaboration
While the Ministry of Health, Nutrition and Welfare will
take the lead in planning for the sector it needs to ensure
full participation of all those involved in contributing to
a healthy nation. The challenge is to involve all partners,
other governmental ministries, the private sector, NGO sector,
and development partners as well as civil society. This approach
should ensure that contributions from donor agencies are well
targeted and contribute to the Government's policy and overall
strategy. |
3.
Aims, Principles and main Thrusts of Strategy
The
Government of Sri Lanka recognises the need to invest in people
to build the human resource base for a just and prosperous
society. Ensuring that the basic needs of the entire population
are met, and that each citizen is given the opportunities
to realize his/her full potential, is central to the Government
strategy to address poverty. It is now widely appreciated
that better health has an important role in reducing poverty
and promoting economic growth.
3.1 Vision
The government aims to foster a healthier nation that contributes
to its economic, social, mental and spiritual well being.
It will achieve this by responding to the peoples needs and
working in partnership to ensure access to comprehensive,
high quality, equitable, cost effective and sustainable health
services.
3.2 Underlying Principles
The vision reflects the fact that:
· People can contribute significantly to their own health
and the government should help them release this potential.
· The role of Government is not just to deliver services
but to develop partnerships, between Government departments
and external agencies which contribute to improving health.
These include:
* Communities in the design, management and use of
services
* The private sector and Non-Governmental Organizations
that play a key role in the delivery and financing of the
health care
*Developmental partners (donor and other international
agencies)
· The Government would ensure that health services are:
* Accessible and affordable to the state and the public
*State services are free of charge at the point of
delivery
*Comprehensive and serve the whole population
*Are of an acceptable quality both in the state and
private sectors
*Responsive to emerging and changing health needs
*Accountable to users and the population at large
*Evidence based
*Sustainable
3.3 Strategic Objectives
The vision of improving the health status of the people will
be achieved through addressing the following strategic objectives:
· To improve health service delivery and health actions
· To strengthen health actions of communities, households
and individuals
· To improve management of human resources for health
· To strengthen stewardship and management functions of
the health system
· To improve health finance mobilization, allocation and
utilization
The aims and the key objectives under each of the strategic
objectives are described more comprehensively in section four. |
4.
Strategic objectives for health development
4.1
Comprehensive Service Delivery
Delivery of comprehensive health services, which forms the
keystone of health development, covers many facets out of
which the important ones are outlined below.
4.1.1 Organization of a Rationalized Health Network
A detailed National Health Service plan for medium-term,
up to 2010, will be prepared relating services to population
needs for primary, secondary and tertiary. This will specify
the optimum configuration of services for a given level of
total annual health expenditure, show the implications for
the state sector of assumptions about growth in private sector
services, and identify priorities for capital investment.
It will take into account, demography and epidemiology, current
and future treatment methodologies, including a gradual shift
to ambulatory care for diagnostic and surgical procedures
and the potential of new technology, e.g. laser and laparoscopic
surgery etc., to reduce inpatient stays.
The national health services plan will be used to guide the
allocation of recurrent and capital financing to provinces.
Mechanisms will be put in place to ensure that this process
is transparent and equitable. Donor investments will fit into
this plan.
In addition appropriate referral strategy including admission
and discharge policies will be introduced to ensure that patients
receive treatment at the most appropriate level. This will
include home-based-care when and where appropriate. The supportive
services too will be developed in a parallel manner.
4.1.2 Priority Diseases/Conditions Reduced through Strategic
Interventions
Sri Lanka will have to continue to deal with existing communicable
diseases while developing programmes for prevention and management
of injuries, non-communicable diseases and new threats such
as HIV/AIDS. Cost effective treatment protocols will be developed
for selected diseases such as cardiovascular disease, diabetes,
arthritis and renal disease and introduced into all relevant
education, training and continual professional development
activities. An example of this is the diagnosis, control and
maintenance of diabetes through community level interventions
with the objectives of minimizing hospitalization and maximizing
quality of life. Pilot programmes will be established to introduce
easy-to-use ambulatory technologies in the Sri Lankan context.
|
5.
The Way Forward
This strategy for a healthier
nation is not an end by itself; rather it is the beginning.
There will be wide consultations on the draft strategy, and
then the agreed strategy will be widely communicated to the
general public, health workers, professional bodies, unions
of health care workers and other stakeholders for comments.
Once finalized this document will be submitted to the Cabinet
of Ministers of the Government of Sri Lanka for approval and
subsequently submitted for parliamentary approval. (Should
this go to the preface?)
The health sector is changing rapidly and the strategy needs
to evolve over time to reflect this continually changing environment.
Mechanisms will be put in place to ensure that the planning
systems and management of the health sector reflects and takes
forward the strategy.
In order to identify possible interventions, projects and
programmes to realize the objectives described above a series
of discussions will be encouraged over the next four months.
These working groups will invite more stakeholders from the
Ministry of Health and Provincial Ministries, other Ministries,
professional groups and other civil society organizations,
which will assist the identification of outputs and activities.
It is expected to conduct seminars and workshops on specific
topics and areas that need further discussion such as health
financing, performance evaluation etc..
Based on the outputs described above, the objectives will
be developed and the broad activities will be identified as
projects and programmes. Once the activities are identified,
the inputs, verifiable indicators and means of verifications
will be determined along with broad budgets for each activity.
Based on the discussions made and the outcome of stakeholder
consultations the detailed master plan will be written by
a group of writers selected from the Ministry of Health along
with international and national consultants.
The most vital component in the strategy is to identify a
number of priority interventions in line with the overall
strategic objectives. The priority should be considered employing
a rational procedure with stakeholder participation as well
as a logical phasing of intersectoral linkages.
Implementing the strategy must be an integral part of the
management of the health sector and not seen as an additional
piece of bureaucracy. Consequently existing structures and
regimes should be used to take the process forward rather
than creating new institutions and structures.
Of particular importance will be the need to use the financing
and planning systems to the best effect. Immediate steps should
be taken to strengthen the Ministry of Health's contribution
towards the development and negotiation of the budget with
the Ministry of Finance. It will be particularly important
to develop clear output measures against which investment
can be measured. Similarly the planning processes should be
improved at an early date to enable transparent plans to be
developed and agreed.
Improved inter-sectoral and donor coordination is essential
to ensure that a sector wide approach is adapted to the development,
financing and implementation of health strategies. The building
of a healthier nation is the onerous and inescapable responsibility
of each and every citizen of Sri Lanka. |
|